While the world is watching the ongoing kinetic war in Ukraine, Russia remains busy conducting “liminal warfare” elsewhere. The liminal space is the gray area between clandestine operations and overt warfare. Putin’s strategy abroad often is to act below that threshold requiring the West to respond. He employed this tactic successfully in Crimea in 2014 and he is conducting liminal operations in Europe today. He cloaks Moscow’s activities, even those that are detected, in ambiguity to hide Russia’s sponsorship. Putin uses a “4D Model” that differs from traditional models of war. It is one the West must get better at recognizing and responding to in the future.
Russian hybrid operations exposed in Moldova this month support the premise that the Shor Party, a Russophile organization, is spearheading efforts to destabilize Moldova’s western-leaning government. “On June 4, the Shor Party and smaller allied groups set up an initiative committee to collect signatures for calling a countrywide plebiscite over Moldova’s external orientation: West, East, or “neutral” in-between. This task will befall the party now taking shape to replace Shor’s party under the same cadres,” according to Vladimir Socor, of the Jamestown Foundation.
The diversity of strategic global security threats today means the West has to anticipate Putin’s moves by adapting to monitor the indicators… Dismiss, Distort, Distract, and Dismay. In 2014 in Crimea, Putin was able to undermine and denigrate his opponents, insult critics and “dismiss” the facts. He “distorted” them so effectively that Russia was able to create a false reality that failed to match the ground truth. Western leaders too often overlook the significance of Russian operations occurring outside the great power nations, in smaller states like Moldova. Using “distraction” in its capital city Chisinau, Putin was able tactically to turn attention away from his operation in the country. He pushed a different narrative to the West asking, “What are you doing around the world?” Fourth, Russia is causing “dismay” in Moldova by frightening its target audience. Ziarul National reported on June 19, that that the Moldovan Constitutional court outlawed the Shor Party whose aim and operations sought to overthrow the constitutional order through unlawful means and that was financed “systematically and illegally” from abroad. But it failed to stop Russia’s operation. Moscow recognizes all that is needed to circumvent the ruling is to change the name of the Party and continue its liminal warfare. The Shor Party was so brazen that after the court ruling its leader Ilan Shor, who earlier fled the country, responded with a paraphrase of an old Bolshevik slogan: “The Shor Party, like Lenin, lived and lives and will live,” according to a June 19 report in the Moldovan publication Realitatea.md. Russia continues to use liminal tactics to aid Shor Party officials. Since September 2022, Moscow has helped the Party to combine socioeconomic demands with strident pro-Russian and anti-Western slogans. Socor says “The Shor Party has upstaged the Socialists in terms of militancy as well as Moscow’s good graces. Russian propaganda has shifted the emphasis of its support from the Socialists to the far more aggressive Shor and his party.”
Using “distortion” Russia encouraged the Shor Party to confront the government with unfulfillable socioeconomic claims to arouse anger among the population. One tactic included spreading information that the Moldovan government is expected to pay the electricity and heating bills of all households for the winter months in full, raise all pensions by 30 percent in accordance with the inflation rate, pay a special Easter bonus to pensioners and other needy people, or redirect the funding received from the EU to social welfare projects, according to the publication Partidulsor.md.
Socor says the Moldovan police has publicized evidence that protesters, angered by the false unfulfilled promises, were paid per diem allowances for their participation. Grey zone tactics can be an effective means to avoid the cost of armed conflict, achieve political objectives using the ambiguity of international law, and ambiguity of actions and attribution. Russia’s short-term political demands in Moldova focus on forcing the resignation of the governing authorities and pre-term parliamentary and presidential elections. Long-term goals are to thwart Moldova’s candidacy for accession to the EU, NATO, and to perpetuate Moldova’s unarmed, unprotected neutrality, which also favors Russia, says Socor.
Moldova is one of many Russia overseas operations using liminal tactics. Russia conducts hostile diplomacy, trade coercion, forced technology transfers, cyber intrusions, and debt dependency on many fragile states. In other countries Russia may lobby or bribe key government and industry personnel, and manipulate the media. Subverting democratic institutions and destroying social cohesion are less expensive tactics than physical warfare, but still dangerous when the goal is to undermine the established rules-based order in the world. Russia is busy in Ukraine, but the West cannot overlook that Putin is active on many fronts, using a variety of tactics to achieve his objectives.
Daria Novak served in the U.S. State Dept.
Illustration: Pixabay